Map: U.S. Census TIGER/LineOpen in map

Pittsburgh classic

The story

Andy Hardie and Dave Tuttle started scooping homemade ice cream on Atwood Street in Oakland, and in 1990 Dave sold his share to Andy. For some 40 years Andy kept it going, never advertising, just letting word of mouth and fresh waffle cones do the work.

When Andy retired in April 2024 and the shop closed, Oakland took it hard. Then the Kasten family, Jason, Laura and Sarah, stepped in. They were family friends, and Jason and Laura had their first date at Dave & Andy's.

They reopened on September 7, 2024 with the same recipes and the same flavors, and former employees came back to show them how it was done. One cone and you'll see why people were so happy to have it back.

At a glance

The basics, from public records.

Dave & Andy's Homemade Ice Cream is an independent ice cream and dessert shop at 207 Atwood Street in Central Oakland, part of Oakland in Pittsburgh.

Its latest Allegheny County Health Department record on file is a reinspection on Oct 3, 2025, which ended with an Inspected & Permitted placard.

Details

From Allegheny County food facility permits. The owner can add the rest.

Address207 Atwood Street
NeighborhoodCentral Oakland
CategoryIce cream & dessert
HoursNot listed yet. Owner can add.
PhoneNot listed yet. Owner can add.
WebsiteNot listed yet. Owner can add.
SourcePittsburgh Spotlight directory (built from Allegheny County food permits)

Health inspection

Inspected & Permitted
Latest inspection on file: Oct 3, 2025 (reinspection). 2 inspections in the past year.From Allegheny County Health Department open data, records dated Aug 11, 2025 to Jul 28, 2026. Matched to this listing by address and name. This may not reflect current status; the Health Department's records are the official source.

Nearby

The closest listings to Dave & Andy's Homemade Ice Cream. 77 places in Central Oakland.

Central Oakland guide

Sources: listing details and inspections from Allegheny County Health Department food facility data via WPRDC (public domain). Story sources: University Times, Dave and Andy's reopening; The Pitt News, Dave and Andy's reopening. Map from U.S. Census Bureau TIGER/Line. Distances are straight line. Listing data refreshed Oct 28, 2026.